The best cargo bike – 12 models head to head

Which is one of the best cargo bike, and the way a lot must you price range? What must you search for, and which is the fitting mannequin for you? You will discover the solutions in our cargo bike group check. We put the twelve hottest cargo bike ideas to the check in Paris, seeing the metropolis in a complete new gentle. On y va!

1. Intro
2. An summary of the cargo bikes on check
3. Which is the fitting cargo bike from our cargo bike group check for you? 7 key standards
4. Paris X DOWNTOWN Magazine! A typical day within the workplace
5. Ocean’s Eighteen – The DOWNTOWN cargo bike group check crew
6. What must you search for when shopping for a cargo bike, and what ought to it’s able to? Our 15 must-have standards
7. Particulars matter – The tops and flops of our cargo bike group check
8. The check discipline at a look – Losers, winners, and suggestions from our cargo bike group check
9. Our cargo bike group check loser: The Benno RemiDemi XL
10. Our cargo bike greatest purchase: The BTWIN Cargo R500E Longtail V2
11. Our cargo bike greatest in check: The Riese & Müller Packster2 70 Touring

Intro

Warning: Not keen on extra selection, journey, and high quality of life? Then please don’t learn on. For everybody else, get able to increase your horizons!

Stealing the Mona Lisa from the Louvre on a cargo bike? Effortlessly host an unforgettable picnic beneath the Eiffel Tower? Distinctive sightseeing tour with the children – such as you’ve by no means seen Paris earlier than? Pull up in model on the stylish Café Parisien? Or move by rush hour visitors and park proper in entrance of the bakery for café au lait and a croissant?

If you already know us, you already know. We’ve been there and executed that – and way more apart from! We spent every week within the cosmopolitan metropolis of Paris, diving head first into the hustle and bustle of the city jungle aboard eleven cargo bikes and one thrilling different, blasting 60 km or extra by way of the town daily – nonetheless lengthy the batteries lasted! And we didn’t maintain again, navigating 4-lane roundabouts, crossing street boundaries, winding our methods by way of visitors jams, using alongside cobblestone and gravel roads. What we discovered are large variations between the assorted bikes, options that didn’t dwell as much as expectations, and some underdogs that outshone the competitors. Oh, and we’ve had the Mona Lisa hanging in our workplace since getting back from Paris. Ocean’s Eleven don’t have anything on us ;).

This cargo bike shootout was probably the most intensive and sophisticated group check we’ve performed thus far, although we’d be mendacity if we mentioned we didn’t even have a blast doing it – along with Parisian locals, our youngsters, Pablo Escobear, and artwork collector Jean-Erique Boetzleau: “Paris – we love you. We’ll be again aboard our cargo bikes. It was unforgettable.”

Nous sommes désolés – we’re very sorry. Not all cargo bikes made it to the end line on the Champs-Élysée on the finish of our cargo bike group check, solely those who proved themselves within the chaos of the metropolis and its romantic suburbs. And the cobblestone promenade alongside the Seine, the commute by way of the Bois de Vincennes to Le Perreux-sur-Marne, and the steep climbs of Montmartre demanded all the pieces from the bikes. After all, Paris being the world’s vogue capital, they needed to minimize a nice determine, too, be it whereas working errands or cruising by the numerous luxurious boutiques. Happily, one of the best cargo bikes are enjoyable, protected, comfy, and simple to trip wherever on the planet, providing a wealth of sensible options. Much less convincing cargo bikes, however, are a chore to trip, even when it’s simply to your native nook café.

An summary of the cargo bikes on check

So that you assume cargo bikes are massive, cumbersome, and unwieldy? Or reserved for helicopter dad and mom and painfully hip millennials? Suppose once more! Cargo bikes are all the trend, however many myths, prejudices, and misunderstandings persist. Be aware: not all cargo bikes are equal.

“Cargo bike” is a collective time period for all kinds of cargo carrying ideas. And there are large variations, even when the purpose of each cargo bike is identical: to move folks and items from A to B as conveniently and safely as attainable. And naturally, they need to look good doing so! In the meantime, there’s a large number of completely different fashions which can be shaking up and altering the cargo bike market, introducing quite a few improvements, new motor methods, intelligent options, all kinds of dimensions, cargo carrying capacities, and catering to a variety of budgets. Small cargo runabout with a folding basket and an built-in gearbox within the motor, fashionable mom-van, reasonably priced workhorse, or full-suspension journey cell? There’s one thing for everybody. The fantastic thing about it’s that almost all cargo bikes are an enrichment to your every day routine and a variety of use circumstances – however not all that glitters is gold.

The excellent news first. There’s by no means been a greater time to search out the fitting cargo bike for you and your particular person wants.

The unhealthy information, you’ll (nonetheless) see half-baked ideas, and the hazard of shopping for the unsuitable bike is bigger than ever contemplating the big number of fashions to select from, particularly when you don’t take note of sure necessary elements and particulars.

That’s why we put probably the most thrilling and related fashions to the check, creating the last word market overview and purchaser’s information.

The check discipline at a look:

* The gross weight restrict signifies the bike’s most whole weight restrict. That features the load of the bike, the rider, in addition to all the pieces you placed on the bike.

Be aware: please don’t be fooled into searching for the most important battery capability or the bottom weight. Numbers are ineffective with out context, and a spec sheet alone can by no means present the complete context. In the actual world, it’s usually totally various factors and the general idea that in the end matter, figuring out how nicely one thing performs at a sure job or whether or not a motor can unleash its full energy. On high of that, you could additionally think about the rider’s particular person necessities, in fact. We’ll provide you with a couple of examples as an instance this.
Probably the most highly effective cargo bike motor can’t generate its peak torque on steep climbs if the cargo bike doesn’t have an appropriately simple gear (which is very frequent with hub gears) or the rider doesn’t know tips on how to shift accurately, pedalling at a sluggish cadence in a gear that’s too onerous. This may get tremendous annoying in hilly cities like Stuttgart or San Francisco, or when climbing Montmartre in Paris. It’s much less related in flat cities like Amsterdam or Berlin, however, wherein case it solely makes a distinction when pulling away at visitors lights and with heavy hundreds!

Which is the fitting cargo bike from our cargo bike group check for you? 7 key standards

Even one of the best shoe is not any good if it doesn’t match. And it’s the identical with cargo bikes. There are a number of various ideas in addition to technical particulars and options to think about. However earlier than you get into the technical particulars of the bike, first ask your self what you need and want:

1. What’s the first use on your cargo bike?

It goes with out saying that choosing the proper cargo bike relies upon closely on what you wish to use it for. As a result of though some cargo bikes cater to a variety of use circumstances, you’ll nonetheless discover cargo bikes which were developed with a particular goal in thoughts. Some are primarily supposed to move youngsters, whereas others are perfect for transporting heavy hundreds and ponderous objects. So, are you seeking to take the children to highschool through cargo bike, or do you simply wish to use it to do your weekly procuring?

2. How adaptable does your cargo bike should be?

When you’ve thought of what you wish to transport, you need to ask how adaptable you want the cargo bike to be. Are you proud of a Eurobox on the rear, or would you fairly desire a foldable transport field up entrance? Would you like the choice of becoming a bench seat for teenagers within the cargo bin, or do you like particular person youngster seats on a rack? Do you want compartments within the cargo bin for small objects, or would you like to have the ability to detach the cargo platform with a quick-release mechanism? How necessary is a rain or anti-theft cowl for you? Would you like the choice of changing your bike from a trekking bike to a child transporter by swapping out the fork? The selection is yours. Bear in mind, nonetheless, that a few of these objects are fast to put in, plug in, or take away, whereas another equipment have to be fitted by the supplier prematurely, and aren’t that fast or simple to vary at a later stage.

3. Who will likely be utilizing the cargo bike primarily?

Since all the cargo bikes on check depend on a one-size-fits-all idea, it’s essential to ask who you’ll be sharing the bike with, if in any respect. As a result of the uni-size idea doesn’t work equally nicely for each cargo bike. Among the larger bikes generally is a bit an excessive amount of to deal with for an individual measuring 140 cm tall, and the extra compact cargo bikes can really feel too cramped for tall riders. So determine prematurely whether or not you’re the one one who’ll be utilizing the cargo bike, or whether or not you’ll be sharing it with completely different riders of various sizes.

4. What else can you utilize your cargo bike for?

Cargo bikes sometimes don’t serve a single goal, however can be utilized in a wide range of methods. What we love probably the most is {that a} cargo bike can function a workhorse in the course of the week and an journey cell on the weekend – assume bikepacking & overnighters. So discover out whether or not the cargo bike is extra of a one-trick pony or all people’s darling.

5. How a lot parking area do you’ve gotten?

Everybody is aware of {that a} cargo bike takes up numerous room, and a few fashions extra so than others. For instance, there’s virtually a metre distinction between the longest and shortest bikes on check, and the bike trailer is compact sufficient to be tucked away beneath sure SUVs with excessive floor clearances. So ask your self prematurely about the place your newest addition to the household will sleep. Consider, with a mean weight of 47 kg, you gained’t wish to carry any of the cargo bikes on check up or down the steps into your condo or basement.

6. What anti-theft features will your cargo bike want?

As all people’s darling, would-be thieves would additionally prefer to get their arms on it, that a lot is for certain. So you’ve gotten two choices: both you’ll be able to babysit your cargo bike, or depend on safe anti-theft safety. Body locks and GPS trackers are nice locations to begin. We’d advise going with the GPS trackers.

7. How would you like your cargo bike to deal with?

Are you somebody who values feeling protected aboard your bike, instilling you and your passengers with confidence, or do you want trying thrills, even exploring unmarked dust roads to nowhere seeking one of the best picnic spot with a view? Or would you like most agility to navigate hectic metropolis visitors? Our check discipline had all of it, and there was no cargo bike on check that didn’t have any of those dealing with traits at the least to some extent. After all, a heavy obligation pack mule gained’t be as agile as a compact metropolis runabout, however when you don’t have a look at the entire image, you’ll be stunned at how manoeuvrable some heavy lengthy john cargo haulers could be, and the way cumbersome and demanding some longtail cargo bikes are regardless of making a compact first impression.

Paris X DOWNTOWN Magazine! A typical day within the workplace

Have we landed up in Amsterdam? It began so nicely, with a predefined check route round our editorial workplace in Leonberg, commuting routes previous Solitude Palace, and a little bit of Stuttgart metropolis visitors for good measure. However then issues began going pear-shaped as we rolled into the town of affection aboard twelve cargo bikes simply in time for Trend Week and shortly earlier than the beginning of the 2024 Paris Olympics. At rush hour, in fact. It’s not just like the French metropolis isn’t busy sufficient as it’s.

We’d be mendacity if we mentioned this group check didn’t push us to our limits and past – assume 18-hour days and no mercy. Nonetheless, with Turbo mode engaged, we made numerous new experiences and possibly noticed extra of Paris than most vacationers do throughout two weeks of sightseeing! Above all, we visited locations that aren’t on any normal must-see record. If you happen to assume Italian visitors is chaotic, you’ve clearly by no means been to Paris! We rode a whole lot of kilometres by way of the city jungle, navigated 3-lane roundabouts, and rode alongside honking sports activities automobiles and exhaust-spewing vans. The place on the planet have we landed?

We navigated slender alleys, raced alongside busy boulevards, and felt like actual Parisians. We rode 40 to 60 kilometres by way of the town centre daily, and visited one of the best golf equipment and bars whereas we have been at it, till the batteries of our bikes and our our bodies have been drained. The good factor about it? The wonderful degree of order amongst the chaos. Folks could drive like maniacs in Paris, however the bike path community is unbelievable. A lot in order that we’ve began referring to Paris as the brand new Amsterdam. From the town centre to the suburbs: you’ll discover bike paths in every single place. Good!

We raced in opposition to 7.5-toners at visitors lights, jumped pink visitors lights with the precision of a bomb squad, and risked greater than ten cat lives within the course of. However why all this insanity? And the way did the Mona Lisa find yourself hanging in our workplace?

The story begins in 1911, when the well-known portray was stolen from the Louvre and solely rediscovered in Italy in 1913. For over a century, the Mona Lisa has captivated folks with its mysterious smile and the numerous theories that encompass it. Paris is synonymous with the Mona Lisa and vice versa: they merely go hand in hand.
And now? Now we’ve acquired the Mona Lisa hanging in our workplace. Artwork collector Jean-Erique Boetzleau joined us in Paris, and he’s assured us that our Mona Lisa is the unique ;). How did that occur? Properly, that’s a narrative for an additional day!

Ocean’s Eighteen – The DOWNTOWN cargo bike group check crew

Free tickets to the Burning Man, anybody? Once we introduced, “we’re going to Paris!”, all people within the editorial workplace instantly raised their arms and wished to come back.
However we weren’t handing out free tickets. We had a transparent mission, and necessary duties to delegate, in any case. Ocean’s Eleven isn’t only a random group of individuals both, is it? 😉 Since George Clooney and Julia Roberts couldn’t make it, we had two additional spots to fill for our Paris mission, and so the world-renowned artwork collector Jean-Erique Boetzleau, aka Erik Bötzle, stepped in with out a second’s hesitation, bringing with him a few years of check using expertise with our sister journal E-MOUNTAINBIKE.

And since our mission concerned way more than simply stealing the mysterious woman with the mischievous smile from the Louvre, we put collectively a staff of 18. Finally, we managed to collect a vibrant check crew made up of locals, cargo bike newbies, our skilled editorial staff, associates, and mama Karin together with her youngsters. We transported all the pieces that wasn’t bolted to the ground – our associates, our youngsters, and even our mascot Pablo Escobear, the cuddly teddy bear. Please enable us to introduce our check crew!

Particular thanks additionally to Nicolas Baisin and Fabrice Fuego Levannier for his or her useful suggestions and assist!

What must you search for when shopping for a cargo bike, and what ought to it’s able to? Our 15 must-have standards

1. Cargo bike ≠ cargo bike

One factor is evident, there are completely different cargo bike sorts, like lengthy johns, longtails, and trikes, however trailers are an thrilling and often way more cost-effective possibility, too. However you shouldn’t select a cargo bike primarily based on kind as a result of you will see that large variations, selection and transport choices inside a kind. And simply because one consultant of a sure kind is sweet doesn’t imply all fashions of that kind are! Insider tip: Don’t decide to a basic cargo bike kind, however at all times go for a precise mannequin that meets your necessities and supposed makes use of. Finally, it’s choosing the proper general idea that counts and determines whether or not it really works for you or not!

2. How a lot battery capability do you want on a cargo bike?

To start with, a cargo bike’s vary doesn’t simply depend upon the battery capability, but in addition on numerous different variables like the load (payload, rider, and bike), motor, and assist mode. Your gear choice is especially necessary because it pertains to the effectivity of the motor, which all comes all the way down to the pedalling cadence. To extend a motorbike’s vary, many manufacturers additionally depend on a modular battery system. That’s, they can help you enhance the full battery capability by letting you add a second battery as an optionally available improve. The likes of Cannondale and WINORA ship their bikes with brackets for a second battery already fitted, simply in case you determine to purchase a second battery at a later stage. Riese & Müller, however, allow you to add a further battery of their on-line configurator earlier than putting your order. The modularity of the cargo bike batteries generally is a decisive issue when deciding which bike to purchase. As a result of who needs to continually watch the battery degree indicator throughout a weekend journey to the lake with their cargo bike as a substitute of taking within the surroundings. With that in thoughts, we advocate being clear concerning the distances you wish to cowl aboard your future cargo bike. If you happen to’ll solely be travelling brief distances with gentle hundreds in flat terrain, then a modular battery system in all probability gained’t be price it to you. Nonetheless, if you wish to be versatile and canopy many miles in hilly cities, a modular battery system could make all of the distinction. If doubtful, a much bigger battery capability additionally means extra using time.

3. Which is one of the best cargo bike motor?

„You are able to do this, mother!” Image this: You’ve packed your cargo bike to the brim, you’re within the blistering solar, and confronted with an excellent steep climb. Which motor do you decide? Mama Karin, whose youngsters repeatedly cheer her on up the climbs, is aware of all too nicely that it may be troublesome even with probably the most highly effective motor.

Earlier than you begin evaluating kWs and torque specs, you need to know that it isn’t simply all the way down to the motor. Whereas the drive unit is on the coronary heart of your cargo bike, even probably the most highly effective motor gained’t get you far with out the fitting gearing and a sensible battery idea. And that’s simply scratching the floor of issues to think about earlier than shopping for your cargo bike. Earlier than you’ll be able to even ask your self whether or not the motor will play nicely with the drivetrain and the bike as a complete, you need to first familiarise your self with the various kinds of motors in the marketplace:

Hub motors on cargo bikes

Because the identify suggests, hub motors are built-in into the hub of the wheel, often on the rear, as a substitute of being bolted to the underside bracket. One instance of a hub-motor-powered cargo bike in our group check is the BTWIN Cargo R500E Longtail V2. Like all the pieces in life, hub motors have professionals and cons. Some provide regenerative braking, for instance, they usually’re usually fairly environment friendly. Nonetheless, that is often solely the case in sure conditions and using circumstances. A standard disadvantage is that they have a comparatively slender energy band, with their efficiency dropping sharply outdoors of the best cadence vary, providing minimal and unsteady assist. For instance, the BTWIN feels very highly effective on flat terrain at over 20 km/h, though you wouldn’t count on that from the bike with the least most torque output within the group check (58 Nm). Nonetheless, when you strategy a steep climb too slowly, the motor bogs down.

Motor/gearbox items on cargo bikes

Motor/gearbox items mix the gears and motor right into a single unit. The planetary gears can help you shift whereas stationary and may also shift routinely as a result of the motor is aware of which gear is probably the most environment friendly due to a wealth of sensors measuring your pace, cadence and energy. Alternatively, you’ll be able to predefine your most popular pedalling cadence, primarily based on which the drive unit selects the suitable gear. For the reason that gearbox is encapsulated within the housing and protected against the weather, such methods could require much less upkeep. Due to the built-in gearbox, there’s no want for a derailleur both, permitting bike manufacturers to pair them with low-maintenance belt drives as a substitute of chains. This might additionally prevent from having to lubricate the chain. One other benefit that advantages cargo bikes particularly is that an inside gearbox could be designed to face up to very excessive forces, which signifies that ebikes with motor/gearbox items could be actual powerhouses. Examples of cargo bikes with motor/gearbox items on check embody the i:SY Cargo P12 ZR and the Ultima Multipath Cargo Compact, each of which depend on the Pinion MGU E1.12 drive unit, and the Valeo Cyclee, although the Ultima comes specced with a sequence.

Mid-mounted motors on cargo bikes

Mid-mounted motors have change into that normal and absolute all-rounders. Mid-mounted motors are available many guises and configurations, with three completely different items and a complete of six fashions from business chief Bosch alone making it into this group check. The Bosch Cargo Line motor could be discovered on 4 of the bikes in our check discipline, specifically developed for cargo use. However different giant producers like Brose, Shimano, and Yamaha additionally provide purpose-built cargo bike motors. They bolt to the underside bracket and could be discovered on virtually each form of ebike you’ll be able to consider, whether or not city, cargo, or eMTB. The large gamers provide complete ecosystems of equipment for his or her numerous drive items. This lets you configure the motor methods to fit your wants with completely different batteries, drivetrain, shows, and remotes. This type of versatility is a good benefit as a result of it caters to a variety of wants and preferences. Fashionable mid-mounted motors are – or could be – actual powerhouses too, offering a energetic trip with loads of thrust, even on a cumbersome cargo bike. Their energy output is proscribed by rules or the boundaries of drivetrains and gearboxes. If the gears aren’t already built-in into the motor as with a motor/gearbox unit, there are two various kinds of drivetrains to select from.

Geared hubs on cargo bikes

Because the identify suggests, geared hubs have the gears built-in into the rear-wheel hub. Because of this, the gears are nicely protected against the weather and repair intervals are additional aside. A helpful function of geared hubs is that they often can help you shift gears whereas stationary. As such, you’ll be able to simply interact probably the most acceptable gear for pulling away whereas ready for the visitors gentle to show inexperienced. Nonetheless, one vital drawback is the restricted gear vary supplied by many geared hubs, which signifies that they’re usually unsuitable for hilly terrain.

Derailleurs on cargo bikes

A derailleur-based drivetrain is the most typical type of gears you’ll discover on virtually each bike. It consists of a cassette and a rear derailleur. The benefit of the sort of drivetrain is that it often presents a comparatively broad gear vary, which makes simpler work of steep climbs. Nonetheless, as a result of the derailleur is totally uncovered to the weather, it requires common upkeep and brief servicing intervals.

Insider tip: Mid-mounted motors with derailleurs or motor/gearbox items are greatest for mountainous topography. Geared hubs often don’t provide a large sufficient gear vary for demanding terrain. Because of this, they rapidly attain their limits in hilly areas with steep climbs. Having the unsuitable drivetrain for the terrain will get tremendous annoying. Nonetheless, if the bike is specced with appropriately simple gearing ratios, there’s nothing to cease you from conquering steep climbs with a geared hub both. Due to the broad ranges supplied by derailleurs, nonetheless, they allow you to keep the optimum cadence in undulating terrain, at all times permitting the motor to unleash its full energy, whether or not you’re on a flat part or a steep incline. That is particularly necessary when hauling heavy hundreds as a result of it should allow you to winch your manner uphill even when you don’t have your individual private cheerleading staff on board, like our tester Karin.

You’ll discover an intensive motor group check of all present motors accessible in the marketplace in our sister publication E-MOUNTAINBIKE.

4. Flexibility is king – How versatile is the bike’s cargo carrying idea?

A cargo bike have to be as versatile as its proprietor. So, when you use your cargo bike to move the identical objects daily, your cargo bike needn’t be very versatile in any respect, it simply must be designed to fulfil one particular goal. However what if you wish to take the children to the nursery within the morning, then rapidly commute to work with nothing however a briefcase, navigating hectic metropolis visitors, and finally hit the barbeque on the lake for a well-deserved post-work drink, all together with your cargo bike? Then your bike should have the required tips up its sleeve. Happily, the manufacturers featured in our group check provide numerous options for optimising your transport system – a big and degree platform usually makes transporting a variety of things a lot simpler.

Whereas a number of the bikes on check had giant transport containers, they tapered downwards, neither accommodating a Eurobox nor two crates of mineral water subsequent to one another on the ground. This makes transporting and loading items unnecessarily troublesome. Some transport bins have excessive sidewalls, which helps shield small passengers however makes loading items tougher. Cannondale present which you can have one of the best of each worlds with the Wonderwagen Neo1, that includes a low sidewall and foot rails. This enables youngsters to get into the bin on their very own, and also you don’t need to raise heavy objects too excessive to load them into the bin. Nonetheless, the rear wall of the bin rises far above the headrests and thus retains the little ones out of hurt’s manner.

The slender racks on the again of longtail cargo bikes are loads much less versatile when it comes to what you’ll be able to stack on to them. Nonetheless, they usually include security rails inside which you’ll be able to place a field, into which you’ll be able to then place your items. If the dimensions of the rail is standardised accordingly, there’s room for a commercially accessible crate, or a Eurobox measuring 40 x 60 cm on the base, which could be very handy. That’s sufficient room to simply accommodate a six-pack of glowing water and several other full procuring baggage. Insider tip: Dividers like on the Riese & Müller Packster2, which let you compartmentalise the big cargo bin, often provide a extra dependable approach to safe your load.

5. One measurement suits virtually everybody – How nicely can the cargo bike be tailored to the rider’s measurement?

160 vs 210 cm? A 50 cm distinction in peak appears comparatively insignificant in comparison with the 215 cm common size of the cargo bikes on check. Nevertheless it makes an enormous distinction in follow. A cargo bike ought to due to this fact be capable to adapt to riders of various sizes, contemplating that almost all cargo bikes are available only one measurement. The truth is, all of the cargo bikes on check take the one-size-fits-all strategy. It could appear a bit ham-fisted at first, however cargo bike producers have developed a number of intelligent options to adapt the match of their cargo bikes to swimsuit a variety of rider sizes, nonetheless. The saddle peak of just about each bike on check could be adjusted through a fast launch clamp on the seat tube. A number of of them even depend on a remotely operated dropper publish, permitting riders to regulate the saddle peak on the fly, and put their toes on the bottom much more simply when coming to a cease at visitors lights. Sadly, nonetheless, not each cargo bike featured right here permits you to regulate handlebar peak by way of a fast launch mechanism on the steerer tube. Of the bikes we examined, solely the Riese & Müller Multitinker presents handlebar peak in addition to angle adjustment, each tool-free. Finally, whether or not you’ll be able to actually accommodate riders of all sizes on only one body measurement relies upon closely on whether or not the one-size-fits-all idea presents the suitable adjustment choices. So, earlier than forking over your hard-earned cash, ask your self whether or not you’ll be sharing your cargo bike with others, and in that case, who they’re. Insider tip: A check trip can by no means harm. Make an appointment together with your trusted (cargo) bike supplier, invite everybody who’ll be utilizing the bike, and every take it for a spin.

6. What should a cargo bike have?

For a cargo bike to satisfy your wants not simply in visitors, but in addition in your everyday life, it have to be sufficiently nicely outfitted with the required equipment. Along with a motorbike stand, mudguards, and anti-theft safety, this consists of an adequately vivid set of lights (entrance and rear!), above all. However there’s extra to it! Visibility and the way it’s achieved is essential too, i.e. passive or lively through reflectors or lights, and the place these are positioned. In case your lights are obscured on the cargo bike, even one of the best lighting system gained’t assist. Total, there are two completely different approaches to the positioning of the lights, however each forged gentle and shadows. If the headlight is hooked up to the mudguard on the entrance wheel, it’s unlikely to get obscured by your cargo or the bin generally, and it factors wherever you level the handlebar. Nonetheless, the sunshine is comparatively low, so it’s much less seen to different street customers and solely illuminates the street immediately in entrance of the bike. If the sunshine is hooked up to the handlebar or the top tube above the cargo bin, it often illuminates much more of the bottom forward of you and presents a large field of regard. Nonetheless, when you pack the cargo bin full otherwise you’ve acquired cables dangling from the cockpit, the sunshine can rapidly get obscured. In case your cargo bike doesn’t have any lights in any respect or simply very unhealthy ones, right here is our insider tip: virtually all motor methods – and thus all motor methods featured within the cargo bike group check – can help you join a lightweight that’s powered by the bike’s fundamental battery. Even when the battery runs low, the system at all times leaves a residual cost to energy the lights, which might be foolish to not make the most of. Whether or not it’s Supernova, Lupine, Busch + Müller, or others: virtually all bike gentle manufacturers provide StVZO (German street rules) authorized ebike lights with a high- and low-beam operate. The Supernova taillight has a brake and emergency brake gentle operate, making it nicely suited to using in visitors, and it’s even gained a Design & Innovation Award. The selection is totally yours, however make it possible for the sunshine isn’t obscured, so you’ll be able to see and be seen at night time. Tires with reflective sidewalls, equivalent to these on the Riese & Müller Packster2, provide a dependable different to reflectors on the bike.

7. Dearer isn’t at all times higher

All of us have a budgetary restrict. Exploiting it and emptying your piggy financial institution not often pays off, as a result of the dearer fashions aren’t essentially higher. Value shouldn’t be crucial criterion when shopping for a cargo bike. It’s the general idea that issues. By way of intelligent design and wise financial savings, seasoned producers can develop greater high quality bikes than new gamers who solely spec the newest, most costly parts.

8. Select correctly: type or operate – or each?

Do you like fashionable appears to be like, clean welds, and daring design, even when it comes at the price of performance? Or are usability, intelligent options, and a complicated transport system extra necessary to you than appears to be like? It’s totally as much as you. In one of the best case, nonetheless, this doesn’t need to be an either-or state of affairs, as a result of good design combines type with operate.

9. Transporting youngsters on cargo bikes

When transporting your youngsters on a cargo bike, you don’t wish to compromise on security. Right here, too, completely different producers provide completely different transport options. Whereas the children are nicely protected by the excessive again and sides across the bench seat of the Cannondale, they’re rather less guarded on the WINORA F.U.B. 2W. Though the children sit comfortably on a padded bench and are strapped in securely, their heads are uncovered. It’s also possible to distinguish between cargo bikes on which the children are positioned in entrance of or behind you. Lengthy john cargo bikes are mostly used to move young children, whereas longtails are helpful from about seven years of age as a result of the kids usually have to carry on by themselves.

10.NO FAT SHAMING! – Not cargo bikes both!

The weights of the bikes in our cargo bike group check differ considerably, starting from bikes tipping the scales at slightly below 36 kg to cargo bikes weighing virtually twice as a lot, totalling 70 kg. Small riders are inclined to desire the featherweights on check, however our group check reveals why you is likely to be taking pictures your self within the foot when you decide a motorbike by its weight alone. Our verdict: Most of the heavier but nicely balanced cargo bikes on check are simpler to trip than their lighter counterparts with much less even weight distribution. And the upper the payload, the extra the bike’s useless weight is put into perspective. You’ll discover this most clearly when making an attempt to get the bike up onto the centre stand, which rapidly made us realise how heavy a lightweight bike could be and vice versa. An excellent centre stand that’s simple to get the bike on and off of has clear benefits. The Specialised Porto, for instance, is troublesome to prop up, whereas the virtually 30 kg Cannondale Wonderwagen is comparatively simple to position on the stand. Subsequently, the load alone shouldn’t be (erm) weighted too closely when shopping for a cargo bike. On the subject of dealing with, it’s not simply how nicely the rider is built-in with the bike, but in addition the peak and place of the cargo platform which can be crucial. In case your cargo bike’s centre of gravity is simply too excessive, the bike’s dealing with turns into extra unstable and wobbly. If you happen to then enhance the payload and maintain stacking your cargo greater, the impact will increase. As with the match, it’s necessary to think about this earlier than taking the plunge and, if attainable, take a motorbike for a check trip at your nearest supplier. Insider tip: If you wish to transport your child(s) with the cargo bike, a check trip with all of your passengers on board is an efficient approach to get a really feel for the dealing with. This takes us straight to the following level.

11. Security first – How necessary is security on a cargo bike?

ABS, fats tires, and full suspension are among the many parts that enhance cargo bike security. Nonetheless, crucial issue can’t be decreased to particular person parts.

As a result of when you’re new to cargo bikes, you’ll need to get used to the dealing with, although you needn’t fear an excessive amount of about your security – at the least when you learn the person opinions rigorously. Amongst different issues, we’ll focus on safety-critical elements and supply sensible tuning suggestions for every bike. Among the cargo bikes on check even boast intelligent security options like ABS. Talking of which, you’ll discover an in depth evaluation of the Bosch ABS braking system in E-MOUNTAINBIKE, our sister publication.
Full suspension on a cargo bike? You solely want that on a mountain bike, proper? Improper! Although you may assume full suspension is a function reserved for analogue or electrical MTBs on the paths, it presents benefits in each metropolis visitors and suburban roads. It doesn’t simply take the sting out of pace bumps, potholes, and curbs, but in addition improves dealing with stability. Even massive balloon tires don’t have the identical shock-absorbing capabilities as entrance and rear suspension that’s been specifically tuned for a cargo bike.

12. Learn how to maintain calm – The suitable theft safety for cargo bikes!

Café au lait, summer time, solar, Paris! If you happen to can’t change off to benefit from the second, worrying about your cargo bike as a substitute, you want higher theft safety!

The batteries of all of the cargo bikes on check, that are often price nicely over € 500, are secured with a key, and the glove compartments on a number of the bikes are lockable, too. To supply additional peace of thoughts, many manufacturers additionally depend on body locks for his or her cargo bikes. More and more, others make use of the digital immobilisers and alarms built-in into the motor methods, particularly on bikes which can be powered by Bosch or Specialised items. This a intelligent and handy answer, which you’ll be able to simply management through the related app. Nonetheless, Riese & Müller provide probably the most complete theft safety package deal along with their RX chip, enabling further providers like a alternative assure, although for a month-to-month charge (from € 60 as much as € 120). GPS trackers just like the optionally available FIT E-Bike Tracker of the i:SY or Velco Onitrax GPS tracker of the Ultima, are additionally turning into a standard function on cargo bikes.

13. Discover your manner round – Built-in navigation on cargo bikes!

Exploring the town on a cargo bike is healthier than on any sightseeing bus. We skilled this firsthand in Paris. And when exploring new locations, a navigation operate is a large benefit. However not all cargo bikes within the check discipline can ship on this level. Bikes just like the Riese & Müller Multitinker or Packster2 provide a rudimentary navigation operate through their Bosch Kiox 300 shows. Nonetheless, all the opposite bikes within the group check with Bosch methods could be retrofitted with shows, thus supplying you with entry to a navigation operate. With the Cannondale Wonderwagen and its factory-fitted smartphone mount, all it’s important to do is clip in your telephone. Insider tip: Get an aftermarket smartphone mount if vital!

14. Which cargo bike will slot in my parking area?

With a rain cowl or the like, it shouldn’t be an issue to park your cargo bike outside. Nonetheless, cargo bikes with derailleurs and chains are considerably extra inclined to rust. That is the place belt-driven cargo bikes are better off, requiring much less upkeep. If you happen to’re brief on area in your storage, you is likely to be within the cargo bikes on check that may be propped upright onto the rear rack for storage. And when you don’t have an influence outlet close by, there’s no want to worry as a result of all however one of many fashions on check have detachable batteries, which is an efficient factor. Generally, cargo bike riders take away the battery from the bike to cost it indoors.

A very powerful dimensions of the cargo bikes on check:

*doesn’t depend as a cargo bike

15. Transporting canines on cargo bikes

After all, in case your passenger has 4 paws as a substitute of two legs, an extended john cargo bike with a big cargo bin up entrance is healthier suited than a longtail mannequin, except you’ve taught your canine to “sit” and “keep” on the rear rack. You’ll discover transport containers for small canines that includes quick-release methods just like the MIK interfaces on the Specialised Porto and Moustache Lundi. With these, your furry good friend may also journey safely on the rear rack. Insider tip: A lot of the cargo bikes on check are authorized to tug canine trailers, which frees up area in your bike for groceries and different items. You will discover the fitting canine trailer for you in our massive canine trailer group check.

Particulars matter – The tops and flops of our cargo bike group check

Tops

Flops

The check discipline at a look – Losers, winners, and suggestions from our cargo bike group check

Now we get to the thrilling half! Beneath, you gained’t simply discover an outline of all of the bikes on check, but in addition the check winner, greatest purchase, check loser, and different fascinating suggestions. Be aware, nonetheless, there is no such thing as a such factor because the one greatest cargo bike for everybody, and even our greatest in check will not be everybody’s favorite. However everybody will discover a good cargo bike that’s good for them! Learn on for an outline and transient introduction of all of the fashions in our cargo bike group check:

The Moustache Lundi 20 Cargo 3

The Moustache Lundi is a stylish-looking lengthy john cargo bike with a modular 1,000 Wh battery idea, thereby providing an extended vary. Due to its intuitive and agile dealing with, the Lundi additionally accommodates rookies. With the MIK interface, issues like containers or youngster seats could be rapidly hooked up to the rear rack. Nonetheless, the general impression is clouded by the considerably outdated Bosch Cargo Line motor system and restricted ergonomics.

The Specialised Porto

The Specialised Porto is a longtail cargo bike that provides steady and confidence inspiring dealing with, handy on a regular basis options, and a well-thought-out measurement and cargo carrying idea. The Porto’s motor system is developed in-house, and it’s superbly designed. Contemplating the high-quality workmanship, the marginally greater value level of € 6,690 appears justified. Alternatively, the considerably cumbersome centre stand, rigid 710 Wh battery idea, and restricted trip consolation go away room for enchancment.

The Ultima Multipath Cargo Compact

The Ultima Multipath isn’t a cargo bike per se, however the ebike could be transformed into one, providing a intelligent transport answer. Regardless of its highly effective Valeo Cyclee motor and speedy commuter capabilities, it solely serves for small cargo bike duties, and presents restricted trip consolation and poor dealing with when exploring past city environments. Though it doesn’t have what it takes to come back out on high in our cargo bike group check, it discovered a spot in our hearts due to its native and revolutionary manufacturing course of.

The i:SY Cargo P12 ZR

The i:SY Cargo P12 ZR lengthy john cargo bike is compact, nicely thought-out, and intensely interesting. Though it hasn’t acquired probably the most carrying capability, it’s acquired a intelligent cargo bin that may be folded up, a low-maintenance Pinion motor system with an built-in gearbox, and an enormous 800 Wh battery capability. It’s perfect for on a regular basis adventures in addition to commuters who don’t simply wish to cycle to work, but in addition run their day-to-day errands. As such, it’s one of the best commuter within the group check.

The Riese & Müller Multitinker Vario

Regardless of its compact design, the Multitinker longtail cargo bike impresses with its giant facet pockets and intelligent transport idea, providing agile but confidence inspiring dealing with, and loads of using enjoyable. It’s probably the most manoeuvrable cargo bike on check. Due to the well-thought-out sizing idea, it could actually comfortably accommodate riders of all sizes. Due to the intensive on-line configurator, it meets the wants of commuters and cargo haulers alike, although it isn’t probably the most succesful trekking bike when venturing past the asphalt.

The WINORA F.U.B. 2W

The WINORA F.U.B. 2W is a basic lengthy john cargo bike, providing a 500 Wh battery capability. The dealing with is demanding, and the dimensions and motor idea are outdated. On a constructive notice, the sensible cargo rails are perfect for benches and youngster seats, and the bracket for a second battery on the cargo bin is smart. Total, nonetheless, the transport idea isn’t probably the most versatile or visually interesting.

The Cannondale Wonderwagen Neo1

The Cannondale Wonderwagen Neo1 cargo bike is the last word lengthy john household van. It comes very nicely outfitted for transporting youngsters as normal, and boasts many intelligent particulars. The dealing with is straightforward to get accustomed to, and the specced parts and motor system go away little to be desired. You’ll be able to even improve the Wonderwagen to a dual-battery system. Nonetheless, it’s much less appropriate for trekking, and it might profit from a neater gear for hilly terrain.

The VEOLO Cargo Trailer

The VEOLO Cargo Trailer will not be a cargo bike as such, but it surely’s a critical rival for cargo bikes nonetheless. Though it isn’t precisely low cost for a trailer, it presents wonderful worth for cash due to a variety of equipment. The trailer is probably the most compact “cargo bike” on check. It’s versatile, versatile and simple to deal with. It’s extremely steady and presents first-rate damping, each on- and off-road.

The Momentum PakYak E+

The PakYak E+ is a longtail cargo bike with a whopping 1,000 Wh battery capability, good for asphalt cowboys, however much less so for off-road trekking. Resulting from its lack of dealing with stability, it’s greatest suited to metropolis visitors. Contemplating the inflexible transport and measurement idea, you’ve additionally acquired to ensure it meets your wants earlier than shopping for. The Momentum PakYak E+ feels most comfy as an city commuter and prefers asphalt to dust roads.

Our cargo bike group check loser: The Benno RemiDemi XL

Resulting from its demanding dealing with and restricted trip consolation, the RemiDemi XL solely serves a small area of interest of cargo bike riders. It’s perfect for individuals who have fallen in love with the retro look and solely intend to make use of it for gentle transport duties on flat terrain. It additionally cuts a nice determine as a classy seashore cruiser, and boasts a powerful 1,090 Wh twin battery idea. In comparison with the extra versatile all-rounders within the check discipline, nonetheless, the Benno can’t sustain and couldn’t ship all through.

Our cargo bike greatest purchase: The BTWIN Cargo R500E Longtail V2

How a lot cash must you price range for a very good cargo bike? In our opinion, it’s precisely € 2,999. As a result of that’s what our greatest purchase, the BTWIN Cargo R500E Longtail V2 cargo bike, goes for. The longtail cargo bike presents unbeatable worth for cash. What units it aside is its intensive vary of normal equipment, and the wealth of equally reasonably priced optionally available extras. Due to its flexibility, it’s a sexy possibility for riders who need an reasonably priced cargo bike that they’ll customise to swimsuit their wants. The intuitive and steady dealing with of the BTWIN Cargo R500E Longtail V2 is an enormous plus too. Even cargo bike newbies will rapidly really feel comfy aboard this bike. Regardless of it’s reasonably priced value, the BTWIN Cargo R500E Longtail V2 delivers a excessive degree of efficiency, and comes specced with a 672 Wh battery. Given its wise spec, it’s simple to see why we selected the BTWIN Cargo R500E Longtail V2 is our greatest purchase. It’s an amazing selection for anybody searching for an reasonably priced but succesful cargo bike.

Our cargo bike greatest in check: The Riese & Müller Packster2 70 Touring

The Riese & Müller Packster2 could also be the costliest bike in our check discipline, however its value is justified by its excellent efficiency. Its versatility lets it cater to numerous transport duties with ease, whereas the trip consolation is unparalleled due to its well-specced and high-quality parts. The Packster2 boasts quite a few intelligent options that make it simpler to move your items, and because of full suspension and knobby tires, it excels in a variety of eventualities. The Packster2 comes with a 750 Wh battery as normal, and could be expanded to an amazing 1,500 Wh within the configurator. You’ll discover different helpful options within the on-line configurator apart from, like an RX chip for anti-theft safety, and an ABS braking system. The Packster2 70 Touring is probably the most versatile all-rounder on check, well-deserving of one of the best in check title. The Packster2 is a worthwhile funding for anybody searching for a top-notch cargo bike that meets the very best calls for.

Wow! Our cargo bike group check has definitely given you an in-depth have a look at the world of cargo bikes. So what are the following steps?

1. Take time to reply the 7 questions above.
2. Dive into the person cargo bike opinions and evaluate the assorted standards together with your solutions.
3. Observe our suggestions, and purchase the cargo bike that’s best for you.

We caught the bug after our journey to Paris and are already trying ahead to extra cargo bike enjoyable. Are you prepared on your personal private cargo bike journey? We’re!

Phrases: Benedikt Schmidt, Robin Schmitt, Rudolf Fischer, Mike Starvation Pictures: Antonia Feder, Robin Schmitt